DON'T YOU BE MY NEIGHBOR
The Perfect Neighbor is a true to life documentary only made more true to life by the fact that there's actual bodycam footage involved. That's right, no cheesy reenactments here, just the real deal kiddies. I mean it's rare that said footage could carry the diegesis of a 97-minute film on the real. With "Neighbor" you wonder how director Geeta Gandbhir did it, how she took I guess found, raw material and made it non-repetitive, non-humdrum, like an endless river. "What's the address of the emergency?" Uh, what emergency. Seriously.
Anyway The Perfect Neighbor is shot in the order of trivial incidences that lead to a sad tragedy at the end. It is edited well, with a little tension that seems to ratchet up every 20-minute interval or so. What hampers the film however is the fact that it's all so cut and dried when it could have delved so much deeper. A woman (Susan Lorincz) makes multiple 911 calls about her neighbors and their kids only to eventually shoot one of them dead through her front door. Yeesh! Lorincz eventually goes to trial and then prison and that's it, movie over, total ball game. I mean you take away Florida's stand-your-ground laws and I'm not sure what statement helmer Gandhir is trying to make here. No come to fruition moment, no revelation, just remnants of a standard, reality legal show sans creeper Keith Morrison at the wheel.
Cray cray residents, Canadian broadcasters, and Sunshine State locales aside, "Neighbor" is like watching an episode of Cops mixed with The Blair Witch Project and an elongated two-part-er of Dateline, blender style. It's involving, with some ominous moments but seems like a rather lukewarm tribute to the lady who got killed at the hands of Susan Lorincz (that would be Ajike Owens). Pitchy "perfect".
Written by Jesse Burleson